CHARMED REVIEWS


Oh My Goddess: Final Goodbyes?

By Lisa Eiseman
Scoopme.com

fi·nal·e
-Something that comes at or forms the end

Stunned.

The end of Leo and Piper?

Trying to wrap our minds around the implications from this season finale will be difficult indeed. Therefore, let's try to move through this two-hour season finale step by step.

The Titans

While it was interesting to see such a formable opponent for the Charmed Ones, it did seem a little wasteful on the writers’ part. The Titans were interesting, but hardly fleshed out. This foe could have easily been created into a five-episode arc giving more depth and challenge for the girls. Allowing for a season "big bad" to fight against. Although the story had small elaborations, it still had gaping holes that would have added to the story if they were filled in.

Why did the Titans blame the Elders for their imprisonment and not the Gods that put them there (besides the fact that the Elders gave the Gods their powers)? What type of relationship existed between Demetrius and Meta, and how was Cronus involved?

While we understood that the Titans were strong opponents, it was still murky as to why they could retain their powers after such a long time. The writers could have helped the believability of the story by giving more background information regarding the Titans. Building more tension and foreboding by using an episode arc instead of pulling this formable opponent from thin air (or should I say ice) would have been more appealing.

Phoebe and Paige

Both women were still in the recovering from the previous week’s problems. Paige was still seemingly angry with men and Phoebe was still "in love" with Jason, or maybe just in love with the idea of being in love. While it seemed that both Paige and Phoebe were just afterthoughts for this episode, they did have some key moments that helped shape this finale.

Without Phoebe and Paige, Piper may have remained a Goddess. Piper needed her sisters to help her through the process of coming home to Wyatt.

Both Paige and Phoebe were simply active in these episodes to bring comedic relief for a more somber tale of the Charmed Ones’ lives. So while the writers may have resorted to some slapstick humor, it did help lighten up the entire finale.

Piper’s Heartbreak

The most compelling part of this entire finale was Holly Marie Combs’ heartbreaking portrayal of Piper. Through the years the audience has seen what Piper and Leo have suffered and overcome for their love. To see everything gone in one episode is so mind blowing we're left speechless.

Throughout the entire episode, it was evident that Piper was trying to put off the obvious knowledge that Leo was going to become an Elder. It is like when you know the fate of something but don’t want that outcome to be realized, so you try to ignore what you already have comprehended. Every scene with Combs and Brian Krause in the second part of the finale were just heartbreaking. The only complaint I have is that it was unfair for Leo to take away Piper’s pain at the end. Showing Piper as accepting to such a life altering change at the end was so unnatural. In a way, it was almost cheating us audience members, since our pain wasn’t taken as well.

Magical Community

It was rewarding for the viewers to see so many previous characters return to help the Charmed Ones. This entire season has been about the Charmed Ones becoming more involved in the magical community, (seeing they have such a powerful and important baby that will play a big role in the magical community) it would make sense that the innocents that have been saved by the Charmed Ones would seek them out again for protection. It also would make sense for those of the community that were able to offer support and protection provided that as well during the crisis. Hopefully, next season this "little community" will continue to grow.

New White Lighter

While many had guessed that the white lighter that came from the future was Wyatt, we were undelightfuly surprised to find that he is not Wyatt and his motivations are still unknown.

Chris’ appearance seemed to be very fortunate and helpful at first, but as he began to manipulate and maneuver everyone around it started becoming evident that his intentions weren’t necessarily good. After Wyatt showed that he sensed that Chris was evil, it probably surprised many viewers. Hopefully, however, Piper will continue to question Chris’ motives and find out what he is really all about.

While I’m hesitant to mention the final scene with Chris and Leo, it would be incorrect to simply ignore it. I’m sure that many will have conflicting views on the implications of this scene since it was really unclear as to whether Chris did vanquish Leo or missed him at the end. While it would be presumptuous to state for certain that Leo was vanquished, it would seem that in this scene it was implied that Leo was vanquished and this would coincide with the "evil" that we see Chris portray in Wyatt’s presence. However, this viewer is holding out for hope that Leo was not vanquished.

Implications and Changes

Numerous implications have been set up with this episode for next year’s season. The girls will have a new White Lighter that may or may not be evil. Piper, Phoebe and Paige will all be raising Wyatt together. Paige may not be staying as a super witch for much longer and venture back out into the work world. And of course, will there or won’t there be a Leo for next season?

Either separately or together, all of these changes will have major implications for the series. For the final Charmed article on ScoopMe! come back and read my Wrap next week so that we can talk further on what this season has done for the series and where the sisters can go next season.

This-and-That:

  • It was nice to see that even though the girls were Goddess, their costumes weren’t too risqué.
  • Alyssa Milano as a blonde just doesn’t work. Add to that the very obvious fact that it was a wig and it was again sad to see the makeup on this show.
  • Can I just vocalize how disappointed I would be if Leo was truly vanquished off screen. Very unfair to the viewers.
  • Fess up, how many of you thought Chris was Wyatt in from the future?
  • Would it be too Terminator to have Wyatt from the future warn his mom about Chris’ evilness?
  • Again, can’t tell you how much I loved seeing past innocents that were saved. Are the writers reading our boards or what?
  • It finally looks like we will get a "work"-able Paige back!
  • Loved Wyatt’s nanny – hopefully Niki Botelho will return next season as Wyatt’s nanny.

 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Review provided courtesy of ScoopMe.com

Home

 
TM & Copyright © 2001 Paramount Pictures. All Rights Reserved. Charmed and subsidiary companies are owned by Paramount/Viacom. The use of materials is solely for entertainment purposes and may be requested to be removed at any time.